GST Library

Login | Register

Best GST Library

Contact Us

Subscription Plans

GST News | Updates

GST Calendar

GST Diary

GST Case Laws

GST Notifications, Circulars, Releases etc.

Act & Rules

Act & Rules (Multi-view)

Act & Rules (E-book)

GST Rates

GST Rates (E-book)

HSN Classification

GST Council Meetings

GST Set-off Calculator

ITC Reversal Calculator

E-invoice Calculator

Inverted Duty Calculator

GSTR-3B Manual

GSTR-9 Manual

GSTR-9C Manual

GST Forms

Full Site Search

E-way Bill

Finance Bill 2024

GST Evasion in India

GST Videos


GST e-books

GST Domains Sale

About Us

Our Services

Contact Us

TaxReply India Pvt Ltd
®
Subscribe Free GST updates on...

Join on twitter

Join GST Group 120
Hindi
English

Remedy available to taxpayer under GST law to get his property released must be exhausted before filing writ petition: High Court

High Court declined to interfere at this stage.

Facts of Case

1. Proceedings against the petitioner under Section 67 of the CGST Act are pending.

2. During the pendency of such proceedings, the Additional Director General, DGGI has attached the bank account maintained by the petitioner in DBS Bank. Such order of attachment is the subject matter of challenge in this writ petition.

Revenue Arguments

Section 83 of the Central GST Act permits provisional attachment to protect revenue in certain cases. Such power has to be exercised in the manner laid down in sub-rule (1) of Rule 159 of the Central GST Rules (hereafter “the said Rules”, for short). However, sub-rule (5) of Rule 159 provides as follows:

Rule 159 - Provisional attachment of property

(5) Any person whose property is attached may, within seven days of the attachment under sub-rule (1), file an objection to the effect that the property attached was or is not liable to attachment, and the Commissioner may, after affording an opportunity of being heard to the person filing the objection, release the said property by an order in FORM GST DRC-23.

This writ petition has been presented by the petitioner without taking recourse to Rule 159(5) of the said Rules.

Objection to the maintainability of this writ petition has been raised by the learned counsel for the respondents by referring to such provision.

Petitioner Arguments

Petitioner has contended that the attachment order passed by the Additional Director General is without jurisdiction, since a cash credit account cannot be attached. Reliance has been placed by him on the Division Bench decisions of the Gujarat High Court in M/s. Formative Tex Fab Vs. State of Gujarat & Ors. and the Punjab & Haryana High Court at Chandigarh in Bindal Smelting Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Additional Director General, Directorate General of GST Intelligence to support such a contention. He has, accordingly, prayed for quashing of the impugned order.

High Court

On perusal of the decision in Bindal Smelting Pvt. Ltd. (supra), it appears that the Court considered the grievance raised before it only after recourse to Rule 159(5) of the said Rules had been taken by the petitioner and an order passed on the objection that was raised. The Court examined the order passed by the relevant authority and bearing in mind the facts as well as the legal position, proceeded to pass an appropriate order.

It is clear that sub-rule (5) of Rule 159 of the said Rules provides a remedy if any particular order of attachment under sub-rule (1) leaves a party, subject to tax, aggrieved. We are of the opinion that such a remedy, as made available by the said Rules, is not an ineffective remedy but on the contrary, if sufficient case is set up, substantial relief can be granted to the objector. It is for the petitioner to satisfy the Additional Director General that for the reasons urged, the property ought to be released from attachment by making an appropriate order in Form GST DRC-23. The position as to whether the impugned order, in fact, seeks to protect the interest of the revenue or is otherwise, including the balance in the current account as submitted by the petitioner, would require a factual examination and determination. Thus, it is all the more necessary that the petitioner exhausts the remedy provided by sub-rule (5) of Rule 159 of the said Rules. Should the Additional Director General refuse to release the property from attachment, a reasoned order is required to be passed and such order could be subjected to a challenge before the appropriate forum in accordance with law.

Since the petitioner has not taken to recourse to sub-rule (5) of Rule 159 of the said Rules, we decline interference at this stage. However, we grant the petitioner a week’s time to approach the Additional Director General under the said provision and if such an approach is made, a reasoned order shall be passed after extending an opportunity of hearing.


Best-in-class
Digital GST Library
Plan starts from
₹ 3,960/-
(For 1 Year)
Checkout all Plans
Unlimited access for
365 Days
✓ Subscribe Now
Author:

TaxReply


Jul 15, 2021


Post your comment here !

Login to Comment


GST News (Updates)


  Read more GST updates...

19
Mar
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
10 Mar

☑ Monthly | GSTR-7

GSTR-7 for the m/o Feb 2024 (For TDS Deductors u/s 51 - Section 39(3)).

☑ Monthly | GSTR-8

GSTR-8 for the m/o Feb 2024 [For TCS collection by E-Commerce Operators - Section 52(4)].

11 Mar

☑ Monthly | GSTR-1

GSTR-1 for the m/o Feb 2024 (Monthly Taxpayers) - N.No. 83/2020.

13 Mar

☑ Monthly | GSTR-5

GSTR-5 for the m/o Feb 2024 [Return by Non Resident Taxpayers - Rule 63 - Section 39(5)]

☑ Monthly | GSTR-6

GSTR-6 for the m/o Feb 2024 [For Input Service Distributors - Rule 65 & Section 39(4)].

☑ Monthly | IFF

IFF for the m/o Feb 2024 (QRMP Taxpayers, Optional) - Rule 59(2).

20 Mar

☑ Monthly | GSTR-3B

GSTR-3B for the m/o Feb 2024 (Monthly Taxpayer - Rule 61) - Either Compulsory taxpayer > 5 cr. or Voluntary taxpayer < 5 cr.

☑ Monthly | GSTR-5A

GSTR-5A for the m/o Feb 2024 [Return by OIDAR Service Providers - Rule 64.]

25 Mar

☑ Monthly | PMT-06

PMT-06 Monthly tax payment for Feb 2024 under QRMP Scheme [Rule 61(1)(ii) - Proviso to Section 39(7)].

Taxpayers have a choice to pay tax either, as per -  

A) Fixed Sum Method OR 
B) Self assessment basis subject to interest on short payment of taxes.
(Notification No.85/2020 - CT)
 
28 Mar

☑ Monthly | GSTR-11

GSTR-11 for the m/o Feb 2024 (Statement of inward supplies by persons having Unique Identification Number (UIN)).

31 Mar

☑ Annual | CMP-02

Last date to opt-in from regular scheme to composition scheme under GST for FY 2024-25 [Rule - 3 of CGST Rules.]

☑ Annual | GTA

Closing Date of window on GST Portal for Opt-in / Opt-out for Forward Charge / Reverse Charge by GTA for FY 2024-25 [Notification No.06/2023 - CT(R) dated 26.07.2023]