🔒

^®

Subscribe Free GST updates on...

Subscribe to Best GST Library of India and get ahead of the rest. Click here for plans.

Director's Salary:
(One Issue - One State - Two Rulings)

Director's Salary has become the most concerning issue amongst directors and companies nowdays. The reason being the contradictory rulings being passed by the various authorities over the issue. In the below article, we will discuss the two contradicting rulings passed by the Karnataka AAR over the director's salary treatment under GST.

1. Salary received by director as employee (or executive director) is not subject to GST under reverse charge: AAR, Karnataka in the case of Anil Kumar Agarwal.

"Karnataka Advance Ruling Authority in the case of Anil Kumr Agarwal has passed a ruling on 04th May 2020 that the remuneration received by director as employee (or executive director) is not subject to GST under reverse charge, as it is the value of the services supplied by the director being an employee. However, if the director receives remuneration as a Non-Executive Director, such remuneration is liable to GST under reverse charge mechanism under section 9 (3) of the CGST Act 2017, in the hands of the company." - Click here for Full Order

vs.

2. Director cannot be the employee of company, therefore salary received by director is liable to GST under reverse charge: AAR, Karnataka in the case of Alcon Consulting Engineers (India) Pvt. Ltd.

"Karnataka Advance Ruling Authority in the case of Alcon Colsulting Engineers (India) Pvt. Ltd. has passed a ruling on 25th May 2019 that the director cannot be the employee of company and services provided by the directors to the company are not covered under clause (1) of the Schedule III to the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. The consideration paid to the Director is in relation to the services provided by the Director to the Company and the recipient of such service is the Company as per clause (93) of section 2 of the CGST Act and the supplier of such service is the Director. Therefore remuneration of directors is leable to GST under reverse charge." - Click here for ful Order

Author’s Note
As you can see that both the rulings have been passed by the Karnataka Authority over the same issue. Author believes that CBIC should clarify the matter in public interest and there is a strong need of time to establish harmony and consistency between advance ruling authorities, otherwise professionals, taxpayers & goverment machinary will end up wasting so much of their precious time over the litigation on similar issues. Please leave your views on the same in comment box.

Thank you!
Author - Mohit Jain
The Author is FCA with 10+ years experience and founder of TaxReply. The Author has experience of handling GST compliances of multiple countries including India.

It is a cinfusing matter now recently Delhi High court ruled Directors salary liable for Gst under revers charge... so a detailed clarification need from CBIC immediately

Rulings by Advance Ruling authorities are proving to be jokes. Normally people say that "rules are for fools". Now AARs are also getting included in above adage.

Directors salary is taxable under GST Act. Schedule III is related to employer and employee cadre. This one is not argued in Anil Kumar Agrawal"s case. This Ruling is only pointed out the Schedule III definition. But, the Rajasthan AAR Ruling is giving the explanation with Supreme Court interpretation in CLAY CRAFT INDIA"s case.
No confusions are eliminated.

Taxpayer assigned to State GST Authorities cannot be assessed by Central GST Authorities and vice-a-versa: High Court

19 Apr 2024   4.84k

Amid GST portal deficiency, GSTN recommends extension of GSTR-1 due date for the month of March.

12 Apr 2024   4.78k

Govt defers implementation of Special Registration, Return Filing For Pan Masala, Gutkha Companies till May 15.

12 Apr 2024   4.43k

GSTN requests taxpayers to check their email and refile their GSTR-3B within 15 days from date of email.

9 Apr 2024   10.39k

GSTN Advisory on new feature of Auto-population of HSN summary from e-Invoices to GSTR-1

9 Apr 2024   5.29k

Quick Links

GST Library

Login
Register
About GST Library
Subscription (Pricing)
GST Updates
GST Calendar
GST Case Laws
GST Case Laws Sitemap
Full Site Search
GST Vides

GST Notifications
GST Act & Rules (Section-wise)
GST Act & Rules (Chapter-wise)
GST Forms
GST Forms (Category-wise)
GST Rates
Classification by CTA (Chapter-wise)
Classification by CTA (Search Tool)
E-way Bill
Finance Bill

E-invoice Applicability Calculator
Inverted Duty Refund Calculator
GST Set-off Calculator
ITC Reversal Calculator
GSTR-3B Manual
GSTR-9 Manual
GSTR-9C Manual

Others

GST e-books
GST Domains Sale
About Us
Our Services
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions

taxreply.com © 2024. All Rights Reserved